Marc Drabkoski Real Estate

Buying a Second Home in Cape May County: What It Really Costs

Most of my second-home buyers have been coming down the shore for years. They know which beach they like and where they get their pizza. What they usually don't know is everything that comes with owning down here. Here's the honest rundown, so there are no surprises at the closing table.

Step one: pick the right town for how you'll use it

The county isn't one market, and towns live very differently:

Ask yourself: Do you want to walk to the beach or drive? Will you be here weekends year-round or just summers? Will you rent it out? The answers point you to the right town faster than any price filter.

Flood insurance: get the quote early

Much of the shore sits in FEMA flood zones, and if you finance a home in one, the lender will require flood insurance. Premiums can swing by thousands of dollars depending on how high the house sits, so I get the elevation certificate and a real quote during attorney review. I wrote a full guide to flood zones here.

Renting it out? Know the rules first

If summer rentals are part of how you'll pay for it, the town's rental rules matter as much as the house. Every town licenses rentals differently, and some neighborhoods restrict short-term rentals altogether. See my town-by-town rental rules guide, and tell your lender upfront how you plan to use the house, since second-home and investment loans are treated differently.

The mansion tax changed in 2025

New Jersey's "mansion tax" used to be paid by the buyer: 1% on purchases over $1 million. As of July 10, 2025, it's now paid by the seller, and it goes up in steps over $2 million:

Those rates apply to the whole price, not just the part over the line. That's on top of the regular realty transfer fee, which sellers already paid. For buyers that's good news at closing. Just know that sellers above $1M are factoring it into their price.

Inspections: worth every penny

Shore houses take a beating from salt air, sand and storms. Plan on:

Don't forget the carrying costs

Property taxes, flood and homeowners insurance, utilities over the winter, beach tags and maintenance all add up. If you'll rent, add licensing, inspection, occupancy taxes and a property manager. I'll help you build a realistic yearly budget before you commit.

My bottom line

A second home down here can be the best thing you ever do for your family. Go in knowing the town, the flood zone, the rental rules and the real yearly cost, and it stays that way.

Thinking about a shore house? Call or text me at 609-827-1903 and let's talk about what fits.

Want the weekly lowdown on Cape May County? Get the free Monday newsletter.

General information only, not legal, tax or lending advice. Confirm details with your attorney, accountant and lender.

Marc Drabkoski, RE/MAX Surfside. Each office is independently owned and operated.

Buying a Second Home in Cape May County, NJ: Real Costs

About Marc Drabkoski

I’m a full-time Realtor serving Cape May County and the South Jersey shore market. I bring strong negotiating skills, detailed market knowledge, and hands-on transaction management to every deal. I have experience closing high-value and complex transactions, including those involving difficult negotiations, property issues, financing challenges, and tight timelines.

Homes for Sale by City

Latest Articles